bonndata catalog
Thumbnail for Decoding Fairness in the Value Chain of the Tagbanua Wild Honey Community Forestry Enterprise. Poster on Tropentag 2016

Decoding Fairness in the Value Chain of the Tagbanua Wild Honey Community Forestry Enterprise. Poster on Tropentag 2016

Open this dataset in the live repository

Important usage condition: Use and redistribution are governed by CC0 1.0. Review and comply with the license before using the data.
Persistent identifier
doi:10.60507/FK2/VGSCLX
Published version
1.0
Publication date
2023-09-18
License
CC0 1.0

Description

One of the traditional livelihood practices of indigenous Tagbanuas in Palawan, Philippines is wild honey gathering from the giant honey bee. In order to analyse the linkages of the social and ecological systems involved in this indigenous practice, we conducted spatial, quantitative, and qualitative analysis on field data gathered through GPS mapping, community surveys, focus group discussions, and key informant interviews. We found that only 24% of the 251 local community members surveyed could correctly identify the giant honey bee. Inferential statistics showed that a lower level of education and higher household vegetation contribute to correct identification of the giant honey bee. Spatial analysis revealed that mean NDVI of sampled nesting tree areas has dropped from 0.61 in the year 1988 to 0.41 in 2015. This reduction on vegetation cover may contribute to reduced bee-human interactions and may also be an indication that commercialising non-timber forest products is not fulfiling its objective of development alongside conservation. Indigenous wild honey hunting and gathering as an ICDP shows the complexity of the social-ecological system of forest communities. It also shows the difficulty of getting a win-win situation out of simultaneous pursuit of forest conservation and rural development. Knowledge shifts can, indeed, occur from the interaction of ecological and social factors and we see that if resource management interventions do not employ a systems approach, it can overlook important feedback. NGO interventions should not only facilitate the learning of visible resource managers like wild honey hunters but of the community as a whole. Purpose: This poster has been presented at Tropentag 2016 session ---> 3.4 Knowledge systems.

Creators

Keywords

environment

Files

Before downloading: Use and redistribution are governed by CC0 1.0. Review and comply with the license before using the data.
FileTypeBytesChecksum
metadata.xmltext/xml28932MD5 a21084e4c19745246a0e278093c5d0f3
type_conference-proceedings.pngimage/png5874MD5 e46a9c41054a5a59d8abe622e2288189

Citation

Till Stellmacher, 2023-09-18, Decoding Fairness in the Value Chain of the Tagbanua Wild Honey Community Forestry Enterprise. Poster on Tropentag 2016, doi:10.60507/FK2/VGSCLX, V1.0

Additional Dataverse fields

Id135
Dataset Typedataset
Internal Version Number6
Latest Version Publishing StateRELEASED
Deaccession LinkNot supplied
Release Time2023-09-18T10:52:15Z
Create Time2023-09-18T09:03:14Z
Citation Date2023-09-18
File Access RequestTrue

Export metadata

Static metadata exports available for this published dataset version:

Complete Dataverse metadata

Citation Metadata

Title title
Decoding Fairness in the Value Chain of the Tagbanua Wild Honey Community Forestry Enterprise. Poster on Tropentag 2016
Other Id otherId
  1. Other Id Agency
    ZEF Data Portal
    Other Id Value
    349f1f08-c713-49bf-87a4-f12a1583caf7
Author author
  1. Author Name
    Till Stellmacher
    Author Affiliation
    Center for Development Research, Department Political and Cultural Change (ZEF A), University of Bonn
Dataset Contact datasetContact
  1. Dataset Contact Name
    Denise Margaret Matias
    Dataset Contact Affiliation
    Center for Development Research, Department Ecology and Natural Resources Management (ZEF C), University of Bonn
    Dataset Contact Email
    denise.margaret.matias@gmail.com
  2. Dataset Contact Name
    Justice A. Tambo
    Dataset Contact Affiliation
    Center for Development Research, Department Economy and Technological Change (ZEF B), University of Bonn
    Dataset Contact Email
    forschungsdaten@uni-bonn.de
  3. Dataset Contact Name
    Christian Borgemeister
    Dataset Contact Affiliation
    Center for Development Research, Department Ecology and Natural Resources Management (ZEF C), University of Bonn
    Dataset Contact Email
    cb@uni-bonn.de
  4. Dataset Contact Name
    Till Stellmacher
    Dataset Contact Affiliation
    Center for Development Research, Department Political and Cultural Change (ZEF A), University of Bonn
    Dataset Contact Email
    t.stellmacher@uni-bonn.de
Ds Description dsDescription
  1. Ds Description Value
    One of the traditional livelihood practices of indigenous Tagbanuas in Palawan, Philippines is wild honey gathering from the giant honey bee. In order to analyse the linkages of the social and ecological systems involved in this indigenous practice, we conducted spatial, quantitative, and qualitative analysis on field data gathered through GPS mapping, community surveys, focus group discussions, and key informant interviews. We found that only 24% of the 251 local community members surveyed could correctly identify the giant honey bee. Inferential statistics showed that a lower level of education and higher household vegetation contribute to correct identification of the giant honey bee. Spatial analysis revealed that mean NDVI of sampled nesting tree areas has dropped from 0.61 in the year 1988 to 0.41 in 2015. This reduction on vegetation cover may contribute to reduced bee-human interactions and may also be an indication that commercialising non-timber forest products is not fulfiling its objective of development alongside conservation. Indigenous wild honey hunting and gathering as an ICDP shows the complexity of the social-ecological system of forest communities. It also shows the difficulty of getting a win-win situation out of simultaneous pursuit of forest conservation and rural development. Knowledge shifts can, indeed, occur from the interaction of ecological and social factors and we see that if resource management interventions do not employ a systems approach, it can overlook important feedback. NGO interventions should not only facilitate the learning of visible resource managers like wild honey hunters but of the community as a whole. Purpose: This poster has been presented at Tropentag 2016 session ---> 3.4 Knowledge systems.
Subject subject
  1. Other
Subject Refinement subjectRefinement
  1. Subject Refinement Value
    environment
Free Keyword freeKeyword
  1. Free Keyword Value
    environment
Topic Classification topicClassification
  1. Topic Class Value
    bee
    Topic Class Vocab
    GEMET - Concepts, version 2.4
  2. Topic Class Value
    forest product
    Topic Class Vocab
    GEMET - Concepts, version 2.4
  3. Topic Class Value
    environmental enterprise
    Topic Class Vocab
    GEMET - Concepts, version 2.4
  4. Topic Class Value
    insect
    Topic Class Vocab
    GEMET - Concepts, version 2.4
Notes Text notesText
This dataset was first published on the institutional Repository "Zentrum für Entwicklungsforschung: ZEF Data Portal" with ID={349f1f08-c713-49bf-87a4-f12a1583caf7}.
Language language
  1. English
Other References otherReferences
  1. NATRIPAL, NTFP-EP Asia

Geospatial Metadata

Geographic Coverage geographicCoverage
  1. Country
    Philippines
  2. Other Geographic Coverage
    Aborlan
  3. Other Geographic Coverage
    Sagpangan
  4. Other Geographic Coverage
    Palawan
Geographic Bounding Box geographicBoundingBox
  1. West Longitude
    118.18818664161536
    East Longitude
    118.80342101652985
    North Latitude
    9.821832124616694
    South Latitude
    9.502333273266968

Expected crawler behaviour

Use a stable, truthful User-Agent with product/version and a working contact URL. Across all IP addresses and HTTP connections used by one crawler identity, allow no more than 5 requests in flight and wait at least 20 seconds between request starts. Crawl URLs listed in the catalog sitemap, including file pages and download URLs when they are published, use conditional requests, honor Retry-After, and apply exponential backoff after errors.

The welcome page may link to the interactive repository for human navigation. Automated clients must not treat that human link as a catalog crawl target.

Read the live machine-readable crawler policy before and during a crawl. Stop crawling when it reports CPU or memory utilization at or above 80% and 80% respectively.